If You Take a Biblical Text Out of Context, It's Just a Con
(Thank you Pastor Kristian A. Smith #TFC)
In a world where sound bites and snippets often carry more weight than full narratives, it’s no surprise that even sacred texts fall victim to misrepresentation. The Bible, a rich and layered tapestry of poetry, prophecy, law, wisdom, and personal letters, is often twisted into a tool of manipulation when verses are yanked out of their original context. When this happens, it ceases to be revelation and becomes a con.
What Is Context, Really?
Context refers to the circumstances that surround a particular text or event—what comes before and after it, who is speaking, who is being spoken to, the cultural and historical setting, and the purpose behind the message. In Scripture, context includes the broader biblical narrative, the book in which the verse appears, the chapter it's in, and even the specific situation it addresses.
Reading a Bible verse without context is like hearing one line from a conversation and assuming you know the whole story—it’s not only misleading, it can be dangerous.
The Power of Context
The Bible wasn’t written in a vacuum. Every verse is part of a larger story—a conversation, a cultural moment, a divine message to a particular people in a particular place in history. Ignoring these elements distorts the truth. It’s like quoting a sentence from a love letter in a courtroom and using it as evidence in a criminal trial—it doesn’t fit, and it wasn’t meant to.
The Danger of the “Con”
Taking Scripture out of context has been a tool of con artists for centuries. It’s how slaveholders justified bondage, how cult leaders control their followers, and how politicians curry favor with religious voters. A verse becomes a weapon instead of a wellspring. This kind of misuse doesn't just mislead people—it can hurt them, bind them, and lead them away from the liberating truth of the gospel.
Even more subtly, misusing Scripture leads to something known as spiritual bypassing—the tendency to use spiritual language or ideas to avoid dealing with real-life pain, complexity, and responsibility. When verses are taken out of context to shut down questions, silence grief, or rush people past their suffering, Scripture is no longer a source of healing—it becomes a band-aid over a bullet wound.
Enter King James: Know the Source
Here’s where it gets even more layered. Many Christians quote the King James Version (KJV) as if it descended from Heaven itself. But let’s be clear: the King James Bible was commissioned in 1604 by King James I of England—a monarch with political motives. He wanted a unified translation that would secure his authority over both the church and state.
King James himself was not a theologian—he was a ruler. He had his own controversies, including accusations of corruption, authoritarianism, and rumored personal scandals. The translators he employed were scholars, yes—but they were also working under royal oversight, which meant certain interpretive choices were made to reflect the political and religious pressures of the time.
This doesn’t make the KJV inherently bad—it is a monumental literary work—but it does mean we must approach it with discernment. Not all language translates cleanly from Hebrew, Aramaic, or Greek. And if your faith is built solely on a 17th-century English translation approved by a British monarch, without ever consulting scholars who’ve studied the original languages, cultures, and manuscripts, then your foundation may not be as solid as you think.
Real-Life Examples (common texts)
Jeremiah 29:11 is often quoted as a blanket promise of prosperity: “For I know the plans I have for you…” But in context, it was written to a people in exile, meant to give them hope while instructing them to settle into a long season of waiting. It’s about resilience, not instant blessing.
Philippians 4:13, “I can do all things through Christ who strengthens me,” is used to pump up entrepreneurs or college kids in preparation of finals. But Paul wrote it while imprisoned, describing how he found peace whether in hunger or abundance. It’s a lesson in contentment—not a motivational slogan.
Without context, these verses can become spiritual shortcuts—encouraging people to skip the process of wrestling, grieving, or growing.
Discernment and Integrity
We are called not just to read Scripture but to study it, to rightly divide it (2 Timothy 2:15). This takes time, prayer, and often community. It means we ask questions: Who was this written to? What was happening? What comes before and after this verse?
Discernment isn’t about being suspicious—it’s about being faithful. Faithful to God’s voice, God’s character, and God’s truth.
Conclusion: Honor the Story
The Bible is not a grab bag of inspirational quotes—it’s the story of relentless love, justice, mercy, and redemption. When we pull verses out of that grand narrative, we reduce it to a cheap con, not the costly truth that can transform lives.
If we truly believe in the power of Scripture, we owe it the honor of reading it whole. Anything less isn’t just lazy—it’s dishonest.
And that’s the real con.
Blacklisted Saint